Father Foy and the Church of St Thomas of Canterbury and the English Martyrs, St Leonards on Sea

John Foy was born in London in 1834, the son of an engineer. Both parents were Irish. He was educated at Ratcliffe College, then St Edmond’s College at Ware. He was ordained as a Catholic priest on the 31 January 1858 and was immediately sent to serve at St Leonards, his only parish. He filled the vacancy caused by the departure of Dr Butt, later Bishop of Southwark, to the Crimea (rather late if he was intending to be involved in a war that ended in 1856). These details are taken from his obituaries, as is the next paragraph.The referred to Dr Butt was John Baptist Butt (1826-1899) who was certainly in St Leonards in 1856.

There are so many newspaper mentions of Father Foy that this post can only be a summary.

His parish reportedly covered at first Eastbourne to Lydd, and inland to Wadhurst. He later claimed that there were only six Catholics when he arrived. This sounds very unlikely, especially as the Convent of the Holy Child Jesus on Magdalen Road housed in the 1851 census scores of teachers and students. Presumably he excluded church institutions. There was no parish church, and a room in the convent was used both for the parish and the convent. When the convent chapel was built, it was the parish church for seven years.

Both Pevsner and the official entry on the Historic England website state that the convent chapel was started in 1850 by the famous architect and designer Augustus Welby Northmore Pugin (1812-52) but only with walls going to the tops of the windows. It was consecrated in 1868 and was completed in 1868-69 by his son Edward Welby Pugin (1834-75).The parish church, though, had been completed in 1866, three years earlier. The assertion that a church without a roof was used for seven years is puzzling.

I could not find Foy in either the 1851 or 1861 censuses.

In the Hastings and St Leonards News, 5 June 1863, Father Foy was present at two debt cases, speaking for the same absent defendant. The cases were Edward Stone v Hugh O’Neill, and J.G. Hickman v Hugh O’Neill.

O’Neill was said to be a former railway constable at Hastings. In the Stone case, Father Foy admitted the debt of £6 1s 9d, and said that the defendant could not pay ‘beyond a small weekly instalment.’

Stone was a tailor in Meadow Road. He said that the work was partly executed whilst a subscription was being got up by O’Neill’s friends, and he had understood that payment would be made out of the money received, which he believed to be £30.

Father Foy replied that the actual amount was £20, ‘which he had been obliged to spend to meet continual sickness and death amongst the family.’ It was then said, presumably by the Clerk, that there had been some evasion of the summons. ‘Eventually’ Father Foy promised to guarantee the payment of 2s per week. In the second case, a debt of £2 19s 5d to Hickman, a payment of 1s a week was promised. Hickman was a butcher on George Street. In the 1861 census Hugh O’Neill had been at 5 Station Road, Hastings, age 46, police constable for the railway, with wife Mary, 40. Both were born in Ireland. They had four children, aged 16 to 21, born in London. The eldest was Mary Ann, who was buried on the 15 November 1862 at Hastings Borough Cemetery.

This is interesting as it shows how far Father Foy was prepared to go to help his parishioners, especially as he promised to guarantee the payments. The debts of about £9 would be valued today at £1020, while the payments of 3s a week would be valued at £17. The subscription amount was about £2267.

Father Foy could also prosecute the rogues. In the St Leonards & Hastings Gazette, 20 Jun 1863, there was the case of James Jackson, described as a ‘pseudo Romanist’, charged with obtaining money by false and fraudulent pretences. He was ‘given in charge’ by Father Foy, described as of All Souls’ Convent. He had visited Father Foy for half an hour and represented himself as a brother of Charity, sent by his superiors to collect for an institution in Lancashire. He was asked to call again the next day but instead visited, claiming he was sent by Father Foy, Dr Duke; Mr Shea, of Warrior Square; and Mrs MacEnteer, of Beach Cottages. He obtained a pound from Shea, and a lesser sum from MacEnteer. Jackson begged that his father, a respectable man, not be told. Jackson was sent to Lewes gaol for three months.

Another case was reported in the Hastings & St Leonards News, 16 December 1864. Ellen Driscol, a Catholic widow, described as ‘well known in the town’, had repeatedly asked for charity at the lodge of the convent. Darby Byrne, the porter, gave evidence about her behaviour. He had had to eject her by force, following which she threw part of a brick at him, and incited one of her children to also throw things at Byrne.

Father Foy pressed a charge against Driscol of disturbing the peace, but he was not present, as he was at Margate. Driscol displayed ‘a most vindictive spirit’, and called Byrne a sneak. She claimed that Father Foy had kept money meant for her, and said her husband had been starved and killed. As Father Foy was not present the magistrates wanted him to attend to reply to that allegation, and both summonses were adjourned, while Driscol was warned to be on good behaviour.

The same, 6 January 1865, reported on the case’s conclusion. Headlined ‘A Mutinous Catholic’, Driscol had continued with her rampage. She had annoyed the Rev. G.H. Haskar of 61 Eversfield Place by frequently knocking on his door, but he did not wish to press charges. Father Foy said that he had never received money for Mrs Driscol, and had attended her late husband on his deathbed, giving him some relief. Mr Langham, the prosecuting attorney, stated that she had ‘gone into the reverend gentleman’s garden and smashed four panes of glass with her fist.’ This was on Boxing Day, she having disturbed the peace on Norman Road East on Christmas Day.

Father Foy denied her charges, and said that she had broken 27 panes of glass at his residence the previous day. Because of her misbehaviour he would have refused to receive any money meant for her. She was sentenced to two months in prison. The account ends with:

On being removed from the dock prisoner gave vent to a series of expressions towards Mr Langham, including wishes that were anything but blessings. She also threatened to do something more when she came out of prison.

Detail from an Ordnance Survey map surveyed in 1872, published in 1875, showing the original Roman Catholic church on Magdalen Road, St Leonards on Sea

On the 7 July 1865 planning application DH/C/6/1/876, for a church on Magdalen Road, was approved. This church was on the same site as the current one but was considerably smaller, and had its entrance at or near the back. The architect was Charles Alban Buckler (1825-1905). The foundation stone was laid on 21 August 1865 and it was opened on 24 May 1866. According to the Ordnance Survey map that was surveyed in 1872 and published in 1875 it could ‘sit’ 200 persons. A separate presbytery for Father Foy’s accommodation was also present at the back, which dated from 1867, as DH/C/6/1/1020 (since replaced by a modern building). The second Catholic church in the town, St Mary Star of the Sea, was not built until 1883.

The Hastings & St Leonards News reported in its 23 October 1868 issue about ‘THE LATE DISTURBANCE AT THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH’, a dispute about wearing hats in church which led to an assault charge against two men. Father Foy was giving a sermon on ritualism, and Edward J. Fullagar, a former school teacher and now a tea dealer, had attended. The witnesses’ evidence given conflicted. First a summary of Fullagar’s evidence in what was a very long account, from which much has been left out by me.

He claimed that at the service’s close he got up and went towards the entrance, and two feet from the door put on his hat to protect himself from the cold. One of the congregation, Thomas Marshall, a former Church of England clergyman, said to him ‘Take your hat off, sir.’ Fullagar replied ‘I shan’t’, thinking Marshall presumptuous. Marshall then knocked the hat off, grabbed Fullagar by the collar, and threw him outside the church. Marshall then said ‘You rascal, do you know you have offended God’s church.’ He demanded to know Fullagar’s name and address, which was refused, and in turn Marshall refused to give such details to Fullagar. Marshall and George Baker, a gentleman who was the other defendant, then tried to drag Fullagar into the church, whereupon a man named O’Neil came out and said ‘You have no right with this gentleman at all. Let him go.’ They did so, and retrieved his hat from a lady who had picked it up. Fullagar had suffered from the shaking since.

The defence attorney claimed that the closing hymn was still being sung when Fullagar got up and immediately put his hat on. There was much about letters being sent and printed, and an interview with Father Foy by Fullagar in which he apologised for his behaviour. Fullagar stated that he did not think it offensive to put his hat on it church, while the Mayor, as one of the magistrates, said that it would be ‘highly indecorous’ to put on a hat in church if ten feet from the door, but not if it were two feet. The magistrates were concerned about the contradictions in the evidence, and dismissed the summonses. I am sure that Fullagar had indeed put his hat on as he rose from the pew.

The 1871 census for Magdalen Road, Priests House, has this household:

John Foy, head, unm, 30, Catholic Priest, born Middlesex London [age should be about 53]

Alexander Newry, visitor, unm, 58, Catholic Priest, born Manchester

Vincent Velasco, visitor, unm, 17, born Spain Madrid

John Dowling, boarder, mar, 53, annuitant, born Ireland Cork

Mary Dowling, boarder, mar, 55, retired servant, born Middlesex London

Father Foy received many intemperate attacks on his faith in the form of letters or meetings printed in the newspapers, and he would doughtily but politely reply either with sermons or with letters. Just one example was when the Hastings & Bexhill Independent, 5 December 1873, gave in detail his defence of the Roman Catholic faith in a sermon to a large and attentive congregation, with the account headed ‘‘Father Foy’s reply to his assailants’.

Before School Board elections were held in 1877 Father Foy wrote a long letter to the Hastings & St Leonards Observer, 3 February 1877. Most of it objected to the Birmingham League, who advocated compulsory, and secular, education. He opposed on both grounds. I have not researched this subject in detail, but in 1871 there was a Catholic school at All Souls’ with 30 to 40 pupils which was free but required church attendance.

Until 1880 he supported the Liberals, when he caused some consternation at a Conservative meeting in the Assembly Rooms. He endorsed the Conservative Parliamentary candidate, Charles James Murray (1851-1929), who served as the Hastings MP for 1880-83, along with the Liberal Thomas Brassey, at a time when the town returned two MPs.

There was a very long account in the Hastings & St Leonards Observer, 26 June 1880, titled “A madman in the Roman Catholic Church. An exciting scene.”

A man named Hogan made his way into the Roman Catholic church on Magdalen Road on Sunday morning. He had already on the Thursday tried to force his way into Father Foy’s house, under the pretence of asking for writing materials, but had been kept out by the servant. In the church he assaulted a man named O’Donoghue, almost 80, who was praying in the church, having a key to gain early admittance. O’Donoghue was thrown to the floor and against the church door. Hogan took the key, while O’Donoghue managed to get away and called for help at the presbytery. Father Foy sent a messenger for the police and went into the church to investigate.

Hogan was kneeling at the communion rail, and turned around on hearing someone enter. The account is rather vague but clearly Father Foy decided that discretion was the better part of valour and retreated, thinking that ‘an overpowering force was needed’ to secure Hogan. On leaving, he met Sergeant Noakes, who entered the church. Hogan attacked him and forced the sergeant out, locking the door. Looking through the keyhole, they could see that Hogan was taking his clothes off. Father Foy feared for the statues and ornaments, while the sergeant feared that Hogan might commit suicide.

Two constables and several cabmen then arrived on the scene. The door was forced open, and Hogan was found just inside. A desperate struggle followed for a few minutes until, near the altar rail, he was held down by all seven or eight men. He was bound with clothes lines and taken to the St Leonards Police station in a hackney carriage. It was mentioned that if he had clasped one of the silver candlesticks he would have been able to commit great harm. No damage had in fact occurred to the church’s contents. The 8.15 am mass was cancelled.

Hogan’s clothes were searched, and a letter addressed to his brother, a surgeon at Bath, was found. This said that he intended to commit suicide in a church. He had previously tried to gain admittance to the Convent but was refused. At a hearing the next day Father Foy was quoted as saying that he looked upon Hogan as a criminal lunatic, and described his assault upon the aged man in the church, and advocated his removal to Broadmoor Asylum. Hogan had been supervisor of the Inland Revenue Office at Hurstmonceux. He had taken apartments at Mr T. Winter’s, in All Saints Street, where he proposed to stay for two months, and had caused much upset.

After the hearing Hogan was immediately taken to the asylum at Hayward’s Heath.

In the 1881 census, at ‘St Thomas priest’s house’, there was this household:

John Foy, head, 46, Unmarried, Catholic priest, born London

Anne Geoghegan, serv, W[idow], 55, servant dom, born London

Mary A. Geoghegan, serv, Unmarried, 25, servant dom, born London

A disaster occurred on the 3 January 1887 with a massive fire. The Hastings & St Leonards News, 6 January 1887:

At about 15 minutes past seven o’clock on Monday morning, a dairyman named Dowell, when passing down Magdalen Road saw smoke coming out of some of the windows of Father Foy’s church. He immediately raised an alarm and sent a boy off to the headquarters of the Steam Fire Brigade in King’s Road. A few minutes later another dairyman named Smith and a policeman (No. 38) arrived at the church, and just then the flames began to burst through the roof. Father Foy, who we are sorry to say is in a very indifferent state of health, was called, and one of his servants ran to the church and unlocked the chief door. The interior of the sacred edifice was then seen to be on mass of flames, and it was impossible to get into the building. At 7.35, the Steam Fire Brigade arrived with their engine and were followed a few minutes later by the St Leonards Section of the Borough Volunteer Fire Brigade… for some time the flames rose to a great height until the roof fell in; the end house in Oxford Terrace was licked by the flames, the wind being from the South West, but by keeping up a continuous flow of water against the building ignition in that direction was happily prevented… water was cast upon the burning debris until nine o’clock when nothing remained of the beautiful little church but the four walls, and the chancel arch. The whole interior was burnt out, and the flames burst through the flooring, leaving only the strong beams, the damage is roughly estimated at from £4000 or £5000, but as several valuable paintings and an exquisite piece of sculpture have been consumed, with the whole of the plate used in the altar services, the total loss may be put down at nearly £8000… amongst the costly things that have been sacrificed are two large paintings by Italian masters, valued at £500 each, three smaller paintings, the property of the Rev. Father Foy, given to him by his parents, a large quantity of carvings, altar accessories, and the elegant memorial sculpture erected to the memory of the late Duchess of Leeds… the vestments and a few other things which were kept in a smaller department at the west end of the building were saved. After the fire, Father Arkell (of St Mary Star-of-the-Sea), whilst searching amongst the ruins, discovered a box of gold relics, which had fallen from the altar into the basement; these were only slightly injured… The church fabric is insured in the Law Fire and Life Insurance Associations Office… since the disaster the Rev. Father Foy has received many letters of sympathy from Catholic and Protestant friends.

The Hastings & Bexhill Independent, same date, adds some more details. A constable had passed on his beat at 6.15 and noticed the gas jet alight which he knew was not unusual. The fire was thought most likely to have been caused by an oil lamp which was always kept burning on the altar [was this different from the ‘gas jet’ ?]. One of the destroyed paintings was called ‘The Salutation.’ Father Foy was described as ‘naturally much distressed.’ He had received communications from five or six of the local Protestant clergymen.

The Hastings & St Leonards Observer, 8 January 1887, had a sketch of the exterior of the ruins. The following week there was a second sketch showing the interior, taken from a photograph by J.H. Blomfield. This was John Blomfield, who in the 1891 census at 43 Cornwallis Gardens was a ‘photographic artist.’ He was advertising at the time that he had photos of Father Foy for sale.

Pen and ink sketch of the ruins of the Catholic church of St Thomas of Canterbury, Magdalen Road, St Leonards on Sea, after the fire. Hastings & St Leonards Observer, 8 January 1887

The Hastings & St Leonards Observer, 5 Feb 1887, stated that a temporary iron church had already been opened and had had its first services. It could hold 200 people, Father Foy stated that Wilson Noble (1854-1917), the local (Conservative) MP, had donated £10 to the new building fund, and added that he was the first MP in 300 years to made a donation to a Catholic church.

The Hastings & St Leonards Independent, 10 February 1887, reported that on the recommendation of the Roads Committee, the plan of a temporary chapel to be constructed of timber, covered with galvanised iron, for the Rev. Father Foy, had been approved. This was subject to his entering into a bond in the sum of £500 to secure the removal of the building within two years from the 7th January, 1887. This was  DH/C/6/1/3387, dated 7 January 1887, so it was very rapidly prepared and then approved. Presumably a known design had been submitted.

The Hastings & St Leonards Times, 19 February 1887, had a long list of subscriptions towards a building fund. These included £2000 from ‘Fire Insurance’, which would have been an unusual donation; £500 from James Ridpath, the treasurer of the fund, of 1 White Rock Villas; £100 from the family of the late Dr Duke; £100 from John Butt, Bishop of Southwark, who had preceded Father Foy as the parish priest; and £10 from the Convent of All Souls. Someone described as a ‘servant’ contributed 10 shillings. The new church would be 30 feet longer and 22 feet broader. While the old church could hold 250 congregants the new one would be able to hold 500. The altar would face west instead of the usual east. This meant the entrance was placed next to the road instead of the previous ‘somewhat circuitous route’.

Not all approved the feeling of kindness towards the bereft Catholic congregation. The Hastings & St Leonards Observer, 5 March 1887 reported that at the AGM of the Ore Conservative Association the Rev. G.F. Williamson had condemned Wilson’s donation, as he was ‘supporting a creed which was so distasteful to Protestants.’ George Williamson was an Anglican clergyman ‘without cure of souls’ in the 1881 census in Hastings.

There was also a small advert placed by Father Foy in the Catholic newspaper The Tablet, 12 March 1887, reproduced below, asking for donations.

Advert by Father Foy to rebuild the burnt out Church of St Thomas of Canterbury, St Leonards on Sea. The Tablet, 12 March 1887

The planning application for the new church was DH/C/6/1/3570. Work commenced on 30 March 1888, the architect being the same Charles Alban Buckler who designed the earlier church. The church was opened in July 1889 but was apparently not consecrated until 1907. I do not know why it took so long. An article in the Hastings & St Leonards Observer, 5 October 1957, marked the golden anniversary of the consecration and stated that it had been performed by the then Bishop of Southwark, Peter Amigo (1864-1949). The article also stated that the beginning of the parish was in 1834 when the Rev. John Jones was appointed priest-in-charge of the mission.

The Hastings & St Leonards Observer, 2 June 1888, had a detailed description of the planned interior. The builder was Mr E. Boniface, a member of the congregation. Boniface had in 1887 built the Jesuit College at Hollington, designed by a French architect. This was St Stanislas, later Hollington Park School for Girls on Gillsman’s Hill. Father Foy had been thinking of enlarging the original church as it was often crowded with visitors to the town.

The Hastings & St Leonards Observer, 13 July 1889, had a very long and sympathetic article describing, on a very wet day, the opening ceremony and high mass, and giving details of the early history of Catholicism at the town. The altar was the gift of Mr and Mrs Boulton, described in detail. Forty French Jesuits were part of the procession of the sacred host around the church. Boys from Miss Stevens’ Catholic school were also present in their ‘little black suits and white sashes’. This was a prep school at St Mary’s Lodge, 6 Pevensey Road.

The present church is Grade II listed and is described in detail on the Historic England website. This includes:

The interior decorative scheme was carried out between 1908 and 1911 by Nathaniel Westlake (1833-1921) blocking an original trefoil window above the chancel arch. By 1945 some of the murals had deteriorated because of water penetration and the wall paintings were restored in the 1950s by the local firm of Pettit Bros. by Gerald and Douglas Padgham who also made their own stencils.

In the 1980s the interior was virtually completely re-done, the major work of restoration being to the mural on canvas to the chancel arch. This work was carried out by Charles Camm. Much of the stencilling was also redone at this time.

The entry includes five modern photos of the interior. While some damage is evident to the murals it is still a very striking interior.

Pevsner’s Sussex: East, 2013, begins its concise description as follows:

As sparing as a friar’s church. Tall and broad, rock-faced ironstone with Bath stone dressings. Lancets, a stepped group of five to the W with boldly detailed buttresses flanking the outer ones. No tower; narthex and mortuary chapel added later. Apsed sanctuary and side chapel. The interior proportions are different as the nave has pointed tunnel-vaulted side chapels, their arches giving the effect of arcades. Timber quadripartite rib-vaulted nave.

The Church of St Thomas of Canterbury and the English Martyrs, Magdalen Road, St Leonards on Sea, as seen from the road

In the 1891 census, the household at ‘Magdalen Rd, Catholic Priest’s Ho’ was as follows:

John Foy, head, S[ingle], 56, Roman Catholic priest, born London

John Higgins, curate, 26, Roman Catholic priest, born London

Mary A. Geoghegan, serv, 33, housekeeper dom, born London

The Hastings & St Leonards Observer, 30 September 1893:

RETIREMENT OF THE REV. FATHER FOY. – After a connection of some thirty-two years with the Church of St Thomas of Canterbury the Rev. Father Foy has retired. We are sure the rev. gentleman will carry into his private life the good wishes of his townspeople, Protestant as well as Roman Catholic. Father Foy is well-known and widely esteemed as a gentleman of kind heart and urbane manners.

The Hastings & Bexhill Independent, 5 October 1893, added that he was to live at Bexhill, to spend his retirement with some priests with whom he was associated in his college days. He was succeeded by the Rev. T. Ottley, of the rural mission at Heron’s Ghyll, Uckfield. The Hastings & St Leonards News, 6 October 1893, stated that Father Foy had been suffering from ill health and increasing infirmity. He was described as a ‘staunch son of the Roman Church and a valiant champion for what he considered her historical rights and her ecclesiastical privileges’, but he did not proselytise. It ended with ‘Father Foy will be greatly missed in many ways.’

The Hastings & St Leonards Observer, 27 January 1894, recounted a testimonial for Father Foy, at his Bexhill residence, 9 Devonshire Road. £100 and a scroll was handed over. Dr Croucher, the Mayor of Hastings, and not a Catholic, led the party of visitors.

Father Foy died on the 14 July 1894 at Bexhill. He was only sixty years old. He left £196 in his estate. His executors were a priest, a solicitor, and Mary Ann Geoghegan, his housekeeper in the 1891 census (and servant in the 1881 census).

The very detailed obituary in the Bexhill on Sea Chronicle, 20 July 1894, said that he had no relatives. As his health declined he had had to drag himself into church. Another detailed obituary in the Hastings & St Leonards Advertiser, 19 July 1894, quoted him as having said that he had received into the Catholic Church some 400 individuals, mainly visitors to the town. Yet another obituary also reported on the funeral the previous day: this was the Hastings & St Leonards News, 20 July 1894. Although a respectful and friendly notice it did describe Father Foy as ‘portly.’

The body was taken from Westbourne Terrace, Bexhill, to St Leonards by hearse, leaving at 9 and arriving at 10 at the Convent of the Holy Child. The coffin was so heavy that it could not be accommodated in his former church nearby, where the requiem mass was held at 11. The front of the altar was draped in black, with silver bordering, and the steps leading up to the altar and most of the chancel floor was carpeted in black. On the catafalque, which normally was a mount for the coffin, were placed Father Foy’s biretta, stole, and a chalice and paten, with three huge candles on either side. Besides a very large congregation there were many priests present, and the mass was sung by the Very Rev. Father Rosette, S.J., Rector of St Stanislaus College. A choir of ladies was led by Miss Stevens. The funeral oration was by Father Richardson of Bexhill, and was given in full in the newspaper. He said that he had taught Father Foy the catechism, and had not seen him after the age of 14 until about a year before. Apparently Father Foy had made a pilgrimage to Lourdes; this appears to have been shortly before a letter by ‘Biblicus’, attacking a belief in miraculous cures as given by Father Foy, in a sermon, was printed in the Hastings & St Leonards News, 8 September 1893.

A procession of carriages then went via the Old Town to Hastings Cemetery, and there was a detailed description of the rites at the graveside. The monumental inscription reads:

The Reverend Father Foy. Parish Priest who for 35 years exercised the sacred ministry in Hastings and St Leonards. Born 12/5/1834 Died 14/7/1894. Eternal Rest Grant Unto Him.

2 thoughts on “Father Foy and the Church of St Thomas of Canterbury and the English Martyrs, St Leonards on Sea”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from The Burtons’ St Leonards Society

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading